Read + Write + Report
Home | Start a blog | About Orble | FAQ | Blogs | Writers | Paid | My Orble | Login
 
As of May 26, 2012, this is now a college football blog by Ren Simon. All previous posts were written by the previous blog owners. Follow us on twitter: Diehard CFB Fans

CFB Week 11 Wrap-Up: Game of the Week, Celebrating Alabama's Loss, ND's Fate, etc

November 11th 2012 19:14
I didnít do well at all in my week 11 picks, going 1-2. Both losses were close, at least. My mother went 2-1, so she is gaining ground on me. Week 11 was one of those weekends that looked like it wouldnít offer that many interesting games. But, boy, if you thought that, you were wrong. Lots of great games, making it very tough to pick the best game. Obviously, Northwestern-Michigan was the best to me, but Iím not a homer...so Iíll pick another game.

Game of the Week

Missouri @ Tennessee. I think a lot of people had basically started marking Tennesseeís last three games as wins for the Vols, meaning theyíd get to 7 wins, a bowl game and possibly save Derek Dooleyís job. Mizzou certainly hasnít been anything to write home about, but if youíre a Tennessee team that canít play D you donít want to let those Tigers hang around. And you definitely donít want to go to overtime with them after theyíd basically been outplayed most of the game. There was poor coaching going on in this game. As poor as Tennesseeís defense is, the offense--particularly the receivers--is good enough that Tennessee could have tried to score at the end of regulation with 20 seconds left. We were just sitting there like, ďIs this dude (Dooley) really leaving two timeouts on the floor?!Ē


What made this game great was the four overtimes, which was like another game on its own. I agree with Tennessee going for it twice on 4th down. One was a fake field goal attempt, and when the Vols were lining up for it I remember saying, ďOh, Tennesseeís going to lose if it goes for the field goal, because the Vols canít stop Missouri.Ē These last three games were must-wins for Tennessee, and 6-6 (with just two SEC wins) is not going to cut it...and you look at Vanderbilt, and Tennessee might not even make it to 6-6.


Honorable Mention: Northwestern @ Michigan, Miami @ Virginia, Kansas @ Texas Tech

Shock of the Week

Texas A&M @ Alabama. This was also truly the best game of the weekend, but it was a bigger shock and thatís why itís here instead. Alabama got Alabama-ed, with A&M dropping 20 on the Tide before they even knew it. Look, SEC--this is what you get for inviting teams that donít belong [geographically] to join the conference. They screw you over. Texas A&M clearly didnít care anything about that precious SEC national title dominance that looks like itís now coming to an end. Instead, the Aggies picked off AJ McCarron twice when other teams couldnít even intercept him just once, and, like LSU, they dominated Alabamaís defensive line. In fact, Alabamaís D was worse in this game than it was against LSU, and part of that was because of Johnny Manzielís mobility.

You do wonder if Alabama would have lost this game if it werenít immediately following the tough road game at LSU. I think the Tide would have. Again, look at how Alabama is struggling against good offensive lines. Plus, McCarron seems to be crumbling under the enormous pressure of expectations. I could tell from the Michigan game that Alabamaís secondary could be exploited if it ran into a QB who really could take advantage of that. We havenít seen the D-line issue, though, because Alabama hadnít faced a stellar line until LSU. Michiganís O-line is weak, and Michigan and Mississippi State are really the only other good teams Alabama had played before these last two games, even though people donít want to acknowledge Michigan and the Bulldogs as good teams.

Iím now very curious about how good Georgiaís O-line is, because I havenít paid much attention to it. My understanding is itís pretty good, although it didnít look that way in some games (South Carolina, Florida). If Georgiaís O-line plays strong in the SEC title game, then Alabama could end up not even winning the SEC.

Honorable Mention: Louisville @ Syracuse, Florida State @ Virginia Tech, Louisiana-Lafayette @ Florida, Georgia Tech @ North Carolina

Other noteworthy items:

1) Notre Dame continues to be blah on the field, but it is also getting everything it needs with each week. That Alabama loss is huge for the Irish. They might still show up at #3 in the BCS, but we keep getting signs that this season the stars are just aligning for ND. Itís really hard to see Oregon losing. I donít care what anyone says--there is not a team left on the Ducksí schedule to which they have any business losing. But the defense is why they could lose and break the door down for the Irish. And I think this weekend confirms what I wrote last weekend about the Big 12 actually being the best conference, when you look at what Alabama and Florida did this weekend. As such, Kansas State might actually be more likely to drop a game than Oregon.

One way or another, donít be surprised if Notre Dame backs into the title game, even though it absolutely does not look like one of the two best teams in the nation.

2) Alabamaís loss is also huge for all of college football. Why? Because the odds are slim that the SEC grabs another national title now. My mother went on Facebook after Alabama lost, and she was surprised to see so many people happy that Alabama lost. I wasnít. I think most of the college football nation is tired of not only the SECís domination, but just of Alabamaís domination. Alabama won the title last season (and in 2009)--why does it need to win this one?

I had mixed feelings about Alabamaís losing. I picked Alabama to win, and I could see that Oregon State might not beat Stanford...so I knew both losses would mess up my picks for the week. But my Wolverines also lost badly to Alabama, and it was easier to swallow when we could say that Michigan lost to the best team in the nation and that Alabama does ďthatĒ to everybody.

At the risk of seeming biased, though--which I think every sports writer, fake sports writer (myself) and sports media member is, no matter how much ESPN guys laugh at the accusation--personally, I donít hate the SEC. Iím from SEC country. Iím always around SEC fans. I hate the way the sports media treats and talks about the SEC. ESPN likes to say ďSEC haters,Ē which is, perhaps, not the correct way to describe 75% or more of the college football nation. I would say itís the media with which we have an issue.

As I wrote last weekend, there are so many teams in the SEC I just donít want Michigan or any other Big Ten team to get matched up against in a bowl game. I know these are remarkable teams at the top of the SEC, and I know Michigan will lose its bowl game. No one has to tell me that, but the media certainly doesnít have to tell me that a thousand times a week, or spend almost entire shows talking about SEC teams (ahem, ďBCS CountdownĒ on Sunday) or spend segments on how much better the SEC is than everybody else (ahem, ďSVP & RussilloĒ).

This is why there are so many people celebrating the Alabama loss, and why so many people are ecstatic over the idea that the SEC wonít play for a national title this season. Thereís a chance that a one-loss SEC team sneaks in there. But, as mentioned, this season seems to be setting up in Notre Dameís favor, not the SECís. Notre Dame is Michiganís rival and all, but Iíd honestly rather see the Irish in the title game than an SEC team. Enough is really enough as far as the SEC is concerned, and it really is so bad that it has driven Michigan fans to cheer for Michigan State, Ohio State and Notre Dame against the SEC, Oregon State fans to cheer for Oregon against the SEC and so on. Itís time for the mediaís love affair with the SEC to end.

3) Texas Tech and Kansas had a really good game on Saturday that probably not many people saw. But there is most certainly one part of the game that a lot of us have seen or soon will see--the Tommy Tuberville meltdown. Some characterize it as a ďslap.Ē Basically, Tuberville went off on an assistant on camera on the sidelines and yanked his headset off his head, which also took his hat off. I read an article after that which called it a ďslapĒ and said he could or should be fired for this incident. Tuberville says he was aiming for the assistantís shoulders or some such crap. He was clearly not. I think Tuberville made the incident worse by saying that, because itís obviously not true.

When I look at it, I interpret it as Tuberville angrily telling this guy something, and he ripped his headset off as in ďlisten to meĒ--just basically emphasizing to the assistant that he wanted to make sure he got something through to him. I think, if this is true, it could have been explained in a way that makes some sense with an apology, although there are people out there who think thereís no excuse. Iím not saying there is. I donít know what Texas Tech should do with Tuberville. But I think the whole thing shows the pressure coaches are under, especially when theyíre in games theyíre ďsupposed to winĒ and the game is not going the way it should. Stuff like this and like McCarronís crying after the game-winning touchdown last week against LSU are two of many reasons why I donít understand people who seriously think ďitís just a game.Ē For so many people, itís really not.

4) Apparently, a report came out before the Georgia game that suggests Auburn is, indeed, leaning towards firing Gene Chizik. I am a little surprised Auburnís going to pull the plug this season, but I canít say I disagree with the decision. I think Chizik might have been fine if he hadnít decided to try to change the offense from spread to pro-style. Stuff like that typically doesnít work over night. The only thing I can think of is that he truly thought heíd have more time at Auburn. If so, it looks as if he thought wrong.

5) So quality of play is not the only thing wrong with the Big Ten. These Big Ten officials are killing me. They made bad calls in the Nebraska-Michigan State game last week, and they came right back this week with the same nonsense. They essentially took a victory from Penn State, saying a touchdown that would have given the Lions the lead was a fumble. And they tried their best to steal victory from Michigan, giving Northwestern first downs--plural--that it clearly didnít have.

6) I didnít see the Georgia Tech-UNC game--who on earth did (on TV)? But I looked at the score scrolling across the bottom of my screen and said, ďWait, is that basketball...wow, thatís the football score!Ē 68-50? Are you kidding me? Thatís basketball scores in the Big Ten. Even worse than that was Georgia Tech was the team with 68 and North Carolina lost.

7) So letís not just talk about Alabama. Major props to Texas A&M, a team I didnít buy at all. I canít believe what the Aggies have done in their first season in the SEC. Can you imagine if Texas A&M becomes a major player in the SEC?

Itís really time to start talking about Kevin Sumlin, too. This guy came in and beat the best coach in college football. So what does that make Sumlin? Real damn good.

A lot of people are not going to get what Iím about to write, wonít like it, wonít understand why itís being brought up. But here goes:

Sumlinís being, what is starting to look like, a remarkable coach is a huge, huge deal. And he is, measured next to anybody. Make no mistake about it. But Iím sorry--his being black is significant, especially being a black coach in the SEC. Black coaches have not really been getting it done in college football. Iím not saying that has anything to do with race, but it does in a way because black coaches are not usually handed the keys to places that have winning potential--thatís more so the source of failure for black coaches. You can think of some places, but a lot of those places also were foolsí gold--Iíd say UCLA, Miami and Washington, for sure. And so many guys have tried and failed at Notre Dame. And I think when you get down to it, as this season shows, Michigan State is Michigan State--thereís really no making it Michigan or Ohio State, and I mean that as respectfully as I possibly can.

But here Sumlin is with the keys to a big-time program in Texas. And now he has a real shot at doing something amazing--becoming known as one of the best coaches in college football. Black, white, Asian--just one of the best, period. Doing this in the SEC? Even more amazing, not just because of how tough the conference is but because of what everyone thinks about the South and race. Sumlin had Houston rolling and was very close to getting the Cougars into a BCS bowl game. Now, black coaches have done something similar elsewhere, but most of those guys moved on to bigger programs and flopped. I looked at the situation at A&M and thought it was nearly impossible, with the program moving to the SEC as Sumlin entered. Boy, has he risen to the challenge, and it makes Texas A&Mís future look really promising if Sumlin could have a 10-3 or 11-2 season in his first year with the program in the SEC.

Charlie Strong at Louisville is another black coach with the potential to someday soon just be known as one of the best coaches in college football, but I think heíll have to move up to a bigger program and conference--perhaps Tennessee, which certainly would be a bigger challenge than Texas A&M--for this to happen.
22
Vote


   
subscribe to this blog 


   

   


Add A Comment

To create a fully formatted comment please click here.


CLICK HERE TO LOGIN | CLICK HERE TO REGISTER

Name or Orble Tag
Home Page (optional)
Comments
Bold Italic Underline Strikethrough Separator Left Center Right Separator Quote Insert Link Insert Email
Notify me of replies
Your Email Address
(optional)
(required for reply notification)
Submit
More Posts
1 Posts
3 Posts
10 Posts
188 Posts dating from April 2008
Email Subscription
Receive e-mail notifications of new posts on this blog:
0

Ren Simon's Blogs

I have no other blogs :(
Moderated by Ren Simon
Copyright © 2012 On Topic Media PTY LTD. All Rights Reserved. Design by Vimu.com.
On Topic Media ZPages: Sydney |  Melbourne |  Brisbane |  London |  Birmingham |  Leeds     [ Advertise ] [ Contact Us ] [ Privacy Policy ]